TheSongSalad's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Boogle 2]

Empty

The art and animation itself isn't particuarly bad, and there clearly is talent involved in the project, it's just that the idea and depth of the flash are seriously lacking.

I get that it's a spam submission, and that spam tends to be, well, spammy. But that doesn't mean it's going to get a good score. I think, had you added some sort of interactivity, or even some sort of plot to it, it could have been a quite good flash. As it is, it's just empty.

It is clear that at least some effort went into this, but had you put more effort into it, it might have garnered a decent score. You do, however, have potential as a flash artest, so don't take this as a critisism of the authors themselves, just as critisism of the length and lack of any sort of point of the flash.

Good spam it may be, but that doesn't make it a good flash.

~ Review Request Club ~.

evan210 responds:

<3<3<3

[1 New Message]

I like it

I like the art style in particular. The way the guy at the end was drawn was fantastic, and what animation there was was nicely done. I would complain that the flash was too short, but there doesn't seem to be much that could be added to it.

That being said, I don't think I can give it much higher than an 8 when the flash is this short. I really think you should flesh your next project out a lot more, keep it up though man!

[: Drugs In Your Head :]

true in a funny way.

actually rather insightful, i really liked it. you make a valid point about the medicinal weed people, that makes a lot of sense.

as does the part about people being hypocritical about what they're doing. me having addictions doesn't mean it's okay for you to have them too.

i doubt you'll respond, but i wanted to ask. would you be okay with drug use if people don't effect others with it? it seems like you would, but i'm not sure.

and for a bit of a flash review. i actually liked your animation quite a lot, particularly where foamy sticks his hands out over the edge of the screen. nice visual humor there. all in all, great cartoon, keep up the good work man.

[Award Wars]

good, however

i did feel there were to many naturo references, as tye1110 said. don't stop animating as you said you would though! this is a great flash!

[Clay Crowd - I C C]

sorry

sorry, but this is the worst flash i've ever seen. no offense.

mattuiop responds:

ITS NOT FLASH ITS CLAY!
THERE IS ALOT OF STOPMOTION ON NG YOU KNOW!!!!!!!!

latest
ok well ill try and flag this comment

[Charlie the Unicorn 3]

nice

i love this series, and i didn't know for a while that it originated on newgrounds. congrats on your off-beat humor man.

[Tribute to Tommy II]

great

i really liked your movie, very funny. i especially liked the tennacious d parody bit. keep up the good work.

psychicpebbles responds:

lol, thanks. When the final version of this movie comes out, It'll be listenable to.

[Street Fighter Epic Ep.1]

wow

best sprite animation i have ever seen my friend. keep up the good work!

[Maker Of Flash]

kinda

this is kinda a cheap knock off of animator vs animation, but it was nicely done. at the start, i thought it was going to be crap because they animation wasn't that good, but later, it got better. it was some good looking stick stuff near the end there. good job, 4/10 3/5.

BryceMedvin responds:

Its kinda inspired by A v.s. A so ur on track :)

[Dante's Inferno w/ Mario]

well

a very good flash, and it's obvious you have talent, but it seems rushed towards the end, what with skipping circles, and everything like that. you started at level two, skipped a few, then were in the last circle. odd, that was. great flash though man.