TheSongSalad's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[Flash Synthesizer]

good idea

i like the idea, and what presentation there was is decent, however, there is a lot to be desired. you need to add something other than just one piano key area to make sounds w/, and the guitar should have a totally different interface altogether. you need drums, a bass guitar, and more instruments as well. it seemed like a quick flash, but adding these things could get you a ten. also, some of the sound quality (the bells) was rather low. the art is alright, but could be better. and you need a way to be able to play more than one sound and more than one instrument at once, and make it into a full synth.

so, overall, good job, but there is so much untapped potential in this flash, i really want to see you flesh it out a lot more. hope i helped, and good luck. 4/5 7/10

ProximityGames responds:

What do you mean by play more than one sound?
If you mean piano keys, then you can play two keys at a time by using the keyboard
thanks for the review. It was very helpful. I will try to add these features if i get the time :)

[Whistle Evaluator]

good idea

i really like this gadget, as it helped me understand what to, and what not to, flag as abusive. it's going to be a great help for people who don't know what they're doing when they flag reviews. also, it was fun to play, making it more likely people will sit through the whole thing. throw in some more reviews to flag (ten is a low number), and an explanation of what you got wrong (seeing as this is supposed to be helpful) and then you'd get the extra two points. excellent idea, excellent presentation. 5/5 8/10

coocooletmoi responds:

Yeah, I certainly will include all that!

[Jinx The Drumming Bunny]

good

i really like the idea because i'm a drummer, and i also like the animation, but i do have some issues, so here goes:

you need to make the drums all register to keys, the only ones i could find were the space bar and the arrow keys, and no high-hat at all.

it seems to lag a little, but that may be my computer, so disregard this if no one else has an issue w/ it.

you need something more than just the sounds, so try something like punk-o-matic, where you have multiple instruments and you get save slots and other animations, etc.

the sound quality is lacking, but i've tried to record my drums before too, so i understand.

overall this is a great little gadget, so don't feel down coz of my issues, i liked it a lot. keep up the good work man.

JMKit responds:

Hey, no that's cool, the feedback is good, i understand how basic it seems and really it was always more of an interactive image than anything, but if i get round to making a new one i'll take all that on board.. thanks!

[{Dev} Function Maker]

okay.

it's okay, and useful to me because i'm converting to as3 from as2. but it took me two tries to figure out the pattern, and so you need something more to add. not horrible, but very small and not very eye catching. good luck.

coocooletmoi responds:

Developper tools are always boring.

[My windows simulater]

could be good, but...

the graphics are inconsistent. the flash window opening looks great, but the 'x' and minus buttons look like crap. also, quite a few buttons do not work. eg, the back button in the opera application. i voted a 2 to pass because i really like the idea, and there's obvious effort, but it needs a lot more polish and detail to be good. keep it up however! add some more to this and give us something to do and it'll be great in no time!

[AS3.0 Tutorial]

very useful

while some parts could have been presented better, or more efficient, i was looking for a good tut to move from as2 to as3 w/, and this was a big help, so it fills its purpose. good job.

[Epic Platform Tutorial]

there you go

you finally got this to be the best tut. it could be. congratulations.

TheShyGuy responds:

Thank you :)

[3 Hours Later RPG.]

eh...

some things you could do to improve.

make it harder to cheat.

up the fps from 12 to maybe 30.

include more to do.

better art.

a good job for just starting, keep up the good work. 5/10, but voted 4/5

[Anime TUT for newbies]

good

a god tutorial for people who don't know these things, like me. however, it didn't look the greatest. and yeah, i know you say your great on paper, but why make this in flash then if it makes you look bad?

deathreaper24 responds:

i dont have any way to show me on paper.